Are journalists con artists? | Summary and Q&A

TL;DR

Journalists grapple with the moral dilemma of taking something from someone for their own ends, especially when dealing with ordinary people who are unaware of the process.

Transcript

do you find you know I have sort of two questions about the sort of subjects that you know when you're dealing with sort of ordinary people or people who aren't accustomed to having attention paid to them do you find that there's I'm gonna well here i'll drop the Janet Malcolm hammer which is I know you've thought about this a little bit but she ha... Read More

Key Insights

• 🤨 Journalism involves taking something from someone for personal gain, which raises ethical questions about the journalist's moral responsibility.
• 🥶 Ordinary individuals may question why they should share their stories without compensation when celebrities gain free publicity.
• 👂 Journalists act as a therapist, listening to vulnerable stories without seeking the same vulnerability from the subjects.
• 😚 The emotional toll of leaving subjects after forming close relationships is particularly evident when reporting on children.

Questions & Answers

Q: Do journalists feel conflicted about the moral implications of their work?

Yes, many journalists are aware that what they do can be morally indefensible, as they take advantage of people's vanity, ignorance, or loneliness. They constantly grapple with the ethical dilemma of using someone's story for personal gain.

Q: Are celebrities and ordinary people treated differently in journalism?

While celebrities may gain exposure and free publicity from media coverage, ordinary people are often left wondering why they should share their stories without any compensation. This raises questions about fairness and the underlying power dynamic in journalistic relationships.

Q: How do journalists justify not offering compensation to their subjects?

Journalists argue that the value lies in sharing people's stories and offering them a platform. However, some individuals may request payment for sharing their experiences, seeing it as a fair exchange for their time and vulnerability.

Q: How does writing about children intensify the ethical considerations for journalists?

Journalists realize that forming close relationships with children during reporting can create feelings of trust and friendship. However, once the story is written, the journalist's exit can leave children feeling abandoned and hurt, highlighting the emotional toll of journalistic relationships.

Summary & Key Takeaways

• Journalists must navigate the ethical challenge of using people's trust, stories, and vulnerability for their own gain.

• Journalists often encounter individuals who stand to gain nothing from their stories, posing questions about fairness and compensation.

• Building relationships with subjects and then leaving them can be emotionally difficult, highlighting the complexities of journalistic ethics.